CONTAINING LINKS TO 1280 STORIES FROM THE NETWORKS' NIGHTLY NEWSCASTS
     COMMENTS: Autism Overkill

The most overcovered malady on the network news agenda was Story of the Day--autism. The decision by a vaccine injury claims fund to pay compensation to Hannah Poling, a nine-year-old Georgia girl, for autistic symptoms she manifested immediately after receiving her shots as a toddler was covered by all three networks. Yet it was the lead on none of the newscasts: CBS and NBC chose worsening foreclosures in the housing market; ABC selected the $10m fine levied on Southwest Airlines for failing to inspect its aging jetliners for metal fatigue.

How fascinated are the networks by autism? Consider statistics for 2007. Autism (59 minutes on the three networks combined) attracted more coverage than any other single disease except for breast cancer (79 min): more than heart disease (57 min); more than tuberculosis--even though the Atlanta bridegroom Andrew Speaker singlehandedly attracted 58 minutes for flying while infected. HIV/AIDS in the entire year accumulated a mere 15 minutes of coverage.

ABC's John Donvan (embargoed link) stated that the Polings are "the first family ever to get its way in a lawsuit blaming autism on vaccines" while NBC's Pete Williams saw the settlement as "a breakthrough, the first federal payment involving a case of autism symptoms in childhood vaccines." CBS' Sharyl Attkisson disagreed. She called it "the first of its kind to become public" but claimed that nine other awards have been paid since 1990. And Donvan offered the caveat that the compensation would be "a huge victory if it is clear cut" but it is not. The fund denied that the vaccine caused the girl's autism. Instead it said she had a pre-existing condition that the shots aggravated "from which features of autism emerged."

Having spent all this time on this single case, CBS anchor Katie Couric had in-house physician Jon LaPook instruct parents not to worry about it. "There is no suggestion that vaccines cause autism," he asserted, citing the Centers for Disease Control. "Aside from clean water nothing has saved more lives than vaccines."


     READER COMMENTS BELOW:




You must be logged in to this website to leave a comment. Please click here to log in so you can participate in the discussion.